Friday, December 21, 2012

Legal options for members to consider URGENTLY


Legal options for members to consider

Members of ADOS, please consider the following
(not exhaustive)

Don’t talk and write and tell others what to do as
Whoever want to implement any thing a process
Of work need to be carried out.

At least those talk and write to others what to do this and that,  show
Us the structure / programme to be feasible with the expected results.

So I would propose lawyers or otherwise , Christians or otherwise
If you want to see justice in BISHOPGATE, please

  1. Please institute a legal suit to review ADOS as a Religious Trust.
  2. Please do a valuation of the Deanery at ASC for the purpose to
Determine the value of rental for a fully furnished detached house of two storeys.
Then file a suit to recover the back rental for 6 years for the abuse of AVCF to allow
Non Dean’s family to stay there.  So we can recover a few hundred thousand Ringgit for
ADOS.
  1. File an injunction to stop AVCF as Bishop for all those violations known and unknown.
  2. many more individual and private suits can be instituted and the fund can be set up for such purpose.

So start thinking and it is still not too late to act.

Joshua

Monday, December 17, 2012

My action against AVCF to be refiled

http://www.dailyexpress.com.my/news.cfm?NewsID=83715
 
Case against Bishop struck out


Kota Kinabalu: The High Court Tuesday struck out with costs the suit brought by a member and beneficiary of the Anglican Church of Sabah against the Bishop of the church over alleged misuse of church funds.
Judge Datuk David Wong made the decision after hearing arguments from both parties and awarded RM5,000 costs to the Bishop.
The plaintiff, Joshua Kong, had on June 26 this year, filed a writ of summons against the Bishop, Datuk Albert Vun Cheong Fui, in his capacity as the Bishop of the Anglican Church of Sabah, as well as himself as the first and second defendants, respectively.
The suit had failed because the plaintiff was found not to have complied with Section 9 of the Government Proceedings Act as the consent of the Sabah State Attorney-General is required before instituting legal proceedings against the Bishop of Sabah (Registered Trustee).
Tuesday was fixed for hearing on the defendant's application to strike out the suit.
The plaintiff's lawyer, Rakhbir Singh, argued that the Bishop had never disclosed anything in his defence. He wanted the defendant to answer the questions on the alleged misuse of funds at a full trial.
The Bishop made no admission to the plaintiff's Statement of Claim against him but relied on his lawyer Ronny Cham to strike out the suit.
During the hearing, Rakhbir had applied to withdraw the suit against the defendant with no cost, but Cham pleaded with the judge to strike out the suit with costs of RM25,000 for the hassle of going through the substantial voluminous documentation, courtesy of the plaintiff.
During the court proceedings, both counsel argued at length for and against the need to strike out the suit just when the plaintiff was applying to voluntarily withdraw the suit.
Cham was insistent that the judge should strike out the suit and not allow the plaintiff to withdraw the suit. He applied for the case to be struck out, which is consequential from the previous order the High Court Judicial Commissioner, Lee Heng Cheong.
Cham said Lee had already ruled on Sept 24, this year that the plaintiff sued the wrong party and the case was brought, by the plaintiff, in contravention of Section 9 of the Government Proceedings Act and also the plaintiff had no locus standi to take the case to the High Court.
He has also tendered to the court on Tuesday, two authorities, one of them stated that without the consent of the State's Attorney General, the case is annulity and it is misconceived.
The plaintiff was trying to withdraw it. It cannot be withdrawn, it must be struck out as a consequential order from the previous proceedings, said Cham.
Wong then asked Cham, "What's the difference? Is it a moral victory that you are looking for? To which Cham said he would leave it to the judge to decide.
Rakhbir, meanwhile, argued that the plaintiff was a poor litigant acting out of public interest and did not stand to gain anything from the suit that he was withdrawing. He asked for no order as to awarding cost.
"The Bishop would not want cost from his people seeking justice," suggested Rakhbir, to which the judge retorted before awarding RM5,000 cost," He has spoken through his lawyer.
Cham when asked after the court proceeding as to whether he was happy with the cost award of RM5,000 instead of RM25,000, said: "The court has decided".
After the adjournment of the case, Rakhbir said that he is a public interest lawyer not out to make money from such pro bono cases and that many Anglican lawyers were backing him.
He claimed the Bishop faces another suit to be filed this Friday by the same plaintiff and another.
Sabah Deputy State Attorney-General Halima Haji Nawab Khan had signed the Certificate of Consent on Nov 16, 2012 for and on behalf of the Sabah State Attorney-General for the two Anglicans to institute legal proceedings against the Bishop of Sabah (Registered Trustee).
Former Sabah State Attorney-General Datuk Stephen Foo was in court to observe the proceedings.


PRESS RELEASE from High Court hearing

My simple and layman understaniding of the Hearing of my Writ against Bishop of Sabah and Datuk Albert Vun Cheong Fui.

My Writ of 26th June, 2012 which was not struck out on 24th September, 2012 when Judicial Commission Tuan Lee Heng Cheong set aside the Court Order/ Anton Piller Order of 18th July, 2012 which could expire automatically on 21 days thereof.   We did not appeal against that ruling.

The Writ has been alive despite  attempts by the Defendants to strike it out in several affidavits and several Court hearings.

Today 18th December, 2012 as adjourned from a brief hearing before High Court Judge Datuk David Wong in OPEN court on 17th December, my writ was withdrawn by my learned Counsel for a refile after some preliminary arguments that my merited action can be sustained with the consent from the State AG on the Section 9 of Government Proceeding Act 1956.

The Judge Datuk David Wong stated the State AG did not give a retrospective consent for the existing suit to proceed.

Counsel for the Defendants argued that the Writ as a consequence of the short ruling by the earlier hearing before Tuan Lee to set aside the Court Order, the Writ should face similar fate on technical grounds and preliminary objections..

After some bargaining on costs on both sides, the Judge decided to award RM5,000 costs to the Defendants.

My counsel Mr Rakhbir argued that the costs should be zero, as it is a public interest and the Defendant case had involved public fund and that merits of the my Writ have yet to be tried and the plaintiff has nothing to gain except to demand justice from a person holding the position of Bishop.

The Defendants’ lawyer was Mr Ronny Cham.

Prepared by Joshua Y. C. Kong, Plaintiff- 18 Dec 2012




Appointment of New Dean of ASC

Did the appointment of new Dean in compliance with the Cathedral chapter in the ADOS constitution?
Why still no transparency of AVCF?

Wednesday, December 12, 2012

Pray with me, my bros and sis in Christ

Joshua, read aloud, proclaim ,claim Joshua Chapter 3 every day for 3 days before 17th December.Consecrate yourself as you face the enemy daily.This is spiritual battle against "...against the rulers, against the authorities, against the powers of this dark world and against the spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly realm. ....put on the full armor and stand (stand firm in the LORD JESUS) Pray daily and commit this case, yourself, your lawyer and the Judge to HIM, ask for wisdom to deal with this case ACCORDING TO THE WILL OF GOD.FEAR NOT FOR THE LORD IS WITH THE RIGHTEOUS MAN.Trust in the Lord with all your heart and lean not on your own understanding; in all your ways ACKNOWLEDGE HIM,and HE will make your paths straight (Pro.5-6).
In Jesus name. Amen!


http://allsaintscathedralsabah.blogspot.com/2012/11/a-day-of-prayer-in-one-heart-one-voice.html#comment-form

Monday, 12 November 2012

A DAY OF PRAYER IN ONE HEART & ONE VOICE 

 

this ascblogs has an error and my many postings did not get through but this one from a prophet got through.

Praise God, Amen, Amen, Amen.

Joshua

Tuesday, December 11, 2012

Education Fund ADOS

Michael Chin Kwet Kyun,
Lot 26, Tmn. Jaya,
Km 4 ½ , Jalan Tuaran,
88450, Kota Kinabalu.
Tel: 019-8329829

Date :  10th December, 2012


The right Reverend Mellter Tais,
Assistant Bishop, Anglican Diocese of Sabah,
Telupid, Sabah.


Dear Sir,

Re Education Scholarship

1. Shalom. Recently I have the opportunity to see a reply from Mr. Paul Liew to Mr. George Lim pertaining to a series of irregularities of the Diocese financial management. Amongst the issues is the education scholarship which I appended for your reference.
                                                                                        
2. Looking at it, there is so many unsavory implications in the awarding of the scholarship to those favoured few mentioned and I do not intend to dwell forensically. I will go straight to the point how I see the whole situation, in the eyes of a lay man and a Christian, more so an Anglican of four generations:

i)                According  to statistic, there are still 30% of the population who live in abject poverty and 60% below poverty line in our country. It means that over half of our parishioners in the Diocese are living below poverty line and I am safe to say that basically majority are our native brothers and sisters in Christ. Bear in mind that Sabah is the poorest state in Malaysia. In this context, I would have expected the award goes to the underprivileged and yet sad to say not even a single child of our native clergies is listed since the conception of the fund.
ii)              A case in point to emphasize a deserving case is the children of the late Rev. Rukuman who died standing (so to speak) to serve God during conducting services. Regardless of what other assistance, be that financial and in kind been given to the widow and family at that moment in time but what after that? Whether in my ignorance or lack of information, though no fault of mine because there never had any accountability or transparency from the Diocese on the fund collection and management. Correct me if I am wrong and I will be glad to hear the number of native Christians children are being awarded.

3. Bishop Melter, I have the highest reverence and admiration for you amongst all the cleric in the Diocese because I have heard a lot of your cardinal virtue as a man of God. Now that this issue out of so many has come to light, I am at loss as to why there is an absolute absence of native being awarded. Taking into consideration the bulk of the clergies and the parishioners in the Diocese are native but I am perplex there is total servitude, submission and resignation to a man rather than to God. Sir, you are the highest ranking cleric amongst the indigenous Sabahan. I am sure your people look up to you. In God’s eyes are we  all equal  and why is our Diocese practicing otherwise ?


4. I apologize if there is any offensive remarks and I pray that the Anglicans in Sabah will rally to the call for restoration of God’s Words, truth, justice, love , humility, servanthood and faith and most important that Jesus is our Lord and Master.

Thank you and may the peace of God be with you.

In God we trust,


DSP (rtd). Michael Chin Kwet Kyun BSK.


                                              
c.c. The Most Revd. Datuk Bolly Lapok, Archbishop of the Province of SEA.

Saturday, December 8, 2012

OPEN letter - Truth & Reconciliation Commission for ADOS - URGENT

OPEN letter in search for quick solution to BISHOPGATE                 9th December, 2012

The Archbishop Most Rev Datuk Bolly Lapok,
Cc The Archbishop of Canterbury, Lambeth Palace.   Bcc:  to all Anglicans in my address book

Dear Brothers and Sisters in Christ, 

Re   Truth & Reconciliation Commission for Anglican Diocese of Sabah (ADOS)

The recent appeal submitted by 10 appellants/delegates backed by a signature campaign of 1,257 Anglicans in Sabah, Malaysia on the untenable position of the Bishop of Sabah in the person of Albert Vun Cheong Fui (AVCF) to the House of Bishops (HOBs) of the Anglican Province of church in South East Asia (APSEA) in Kuching on 7th and 8th November, 2012.  Then a full HOBs meeting was held in Kuching on 28th November, 2012 lacking urgency.  Many expected final proper decision in the first meeting early November, 2012.

The appeal aka Project Nehemiah (PN) was based on the unsatisfactory and unconstitutionally decision of HOBs on 18th September, 2012 after a Provincial Advisory Committee (PAC) of HOBs set up in late May, 2012 on the complain of 5 concerned members of Anglican Diocese of Sabah.

Since APSEA and PAC had gathered the facts/truth of ADOS and issued a full CONFIDENTIAL report in late August 2012 with 38 issues as admitted wrongdoings out of  40 raised in the investigations of PAC since May, 2012, it is strongly believed that the Ecclesiastical Court (E-Court) should have been approved.

In the appeal of 10 delegates, it was reported that AVCF has two choices namely resign or face the E-Court.  If HOBs functioning as Judges on 11th September, 2012, then on 28th November, 2012 had been seen ineffective and so would E-Court with the same Judges/bishops plus a few more persons lacking in relevant experiece could not do any better and any further delay would work against ADOS and APSEA.

We are aware of the reasons of the delay for appropriate actions by the provincial HOBs.  
Any further delay including proposal for E-Court is definitely unacceptable in whatever ways we may look at the BISHOPGATE. 

Looking back now how I wished APSEA had in May, 2012 or even earlier instituted the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) [thinking out of the box] within the Anglican context and terms of reference for BISHOPGATE.  Maybe it is still feasible for HOB to consider that a Truth and Reconciliation Commission be set up with the suspension of AVCF to find a prompt, lasting and possibly superior solution including a revamp post ADOS BISHOPGATE for APSEA and the global Anglican communion?.  PAC was very restrictive and TRC would certainly be more transparent with the complicity and complexity of BISHOPGATE.  PAC also did not interview all those senior priests who left ADOS since 2005/2006. 

Let the superior TRC instead of E-Court be conducted by PN under the supervision/guidance of APSEA to provide the impetus for immediate action to resolve BISHOPGATE for normality to return to ADOS as soon as possible.  The decision of HOBs on 18th September, 2012 has actually worsened the crisis in ADOS and how would AVCF going on Sabbatical leave in February, 2013  resolve BISHOPGATE when he remains Bishop of Sabah?

I trust my suggestion would be considered promptly.

Yours truly,

Joshua Y. C. Kong

D'Sulaman Anglican Church

Dear Anglican members,

Please do some research about the total cost of this church especially bought for Ms Sonia.

Ms Sonia lives in an apartment nearby.

This is a building of 5 stories.

How does AVCF intend to use this 5 storeyed building as a church when the congregation is very small?

Is AVCF making another white elephant like Kokol Prayer Summit costing anything like RM8m.

So APSEA must sack AVCF to save ADOS immediately.

Like this special case as there is a church Christ The King nearby, it is a red herring, and so who was entitled to stay in the Deanery in All Saints' Cathedral when the acting Dean was also Bishop.

Why Stella Lo was entitled to stay in the Deanery?  Your guess please...isn't it for the Dean's family only???