http://www.dailyexpress.com.my/news.cfm?NewsID=83715
Case against Bishop struck out
Kota Kinabalu: The High Court Tuesday struck out with costs the
suit brought by a member and beneficiary of the Anglican Church of Sabah
against the Bishop of the church over alleged misuse of church funds.
Judge Datuk David Wong made the decision after hearing arguments from both parties and awarded RM5,000 costs to the Bishop.
The plaintiff, Joshua Kong, had on June 26 this year, filed a writ of
summons against the Bishop, Datuk Albert Vun Cheong Fui, in his
capacity as the Bishop of the Anglican Church of Sabah, as well as
himself as the first and second defendants, respectively.
The suit had failed because the plaintiff was found not to have complied
with Section 9 of the Government Proceedings Act as the consent of the
Sabah State Attorney-General is required before instituting legal
proceedings against the Bishop of Sabah (Registered Trustee).
Tuesday was fixed for hearing on the defendant's application to strike out the suit.
The plaintiff's lawyer, Rakhbir Singh, argued that the Bishop had never
disclosed anything in his defence. He wanted the defendant to answer the
questions on the alleged misuse of funds at a full trial.
The Bishop made no admission to the plaintiff's Statement of Claim
against him but relied on his lawyer Ronny Cham to strike out the suit.
During the hearing, Rakhbir had applied to withdraw the suit against the
defendant with no cost, but Cham pleaded with the judge to strike out
the suit with costs of RM25,000 for the hassle of going through the
substantial voluminous documentation, courtesy of the plaintiff.
During the court proceedings, both counsel argued at length for and
against the need to strike out the suit just when the plaintiff was
applying to voluntarily withdraw the suit.
Cham was insistent that the judge should strike out the suit and not
allow the plaintiff to withdraw the suit. He applied for the case to be
struck out, which is consequential from the previous order the High
Court Judicial Commissioner, Lee Heng Cheong.
Cham said Lee had already ruled on Sept 24, this year that the plaintiff
sued the wrong party and the case was brought, by the plaintiff, in
contravention of Section 9 of the Government Proceedings Act and also
the plaintiff had no locus standi to take the case to the High Court.
He has also tendered to the court on Tuesday, two authorities, one of
them stated that without the consent of the State's Attorney General,
the case is annulity and it is misconceived.
The plaintiff was trying to withdraw it. It cannot be withdrawn, it must
be struck out as a consequential order from the previous proceedings,
said Cham.
Wong then asked Cham, "What's the difference?
Is it a moral victory that
you are looking for? To which Cham said he would leave it to the judge
to decide.
Rakhbir, meanwhile, argued that the plaintiff was a poor litigant acting
out of public interest and did not stand to gain anything from the suit
that he was withdrawing. He asked for no order as to awarding cost.
"The Bishop would not want cost from his people seeking justice,"
suggested Rakhbir, to which the judge retorted before awarding RM5,000
cost," He has spoken through his lawyer.
Cham when asked after the court proceeding as to whether he was happy
with the cost award of RM5,000 instead of RM25,000, said: "The court has
decided".
After the adjournment of the case, Rakhbir said that he is a public
interest lawyer not out to make money from such pro bono cases and that
many Anglican lawyers were backing him.
He claimed the Bishop faces another suit to be filed this Friday by the same plaintiff and another.
Sabah Deputy State Attorney-General Halima Haji Nawab Khan had signed
the Certificate of Consent on Nov 16, 2012 for and on behalf of the
Sabah State Attorney-General for the two Anglicans to institute legal
proceedings against the Bishop of Sabah (Registered Trustee).
Former Sabah State Attorney-General Datuk Stephen Foo was in court to observe the proceedings.
PRESS
RELEASE from High Court hearing
My simple
and layman understaniding of the Hearing of my Writ against Bishop of Sabah and
Datuk Albert Vun Cheong Fui.
My Writ of
26th June, 2012 which was not struck out on 24th
September, 2012 when Judicial Commission Tuan Lee Heng Cheong set aside the
Court Order/ Anton Piller Order of 18th July, 2012 which could
expire automatically on 21 days thereof. We did not appeal against that ruling.
The Writ has
been alive despite attempts by the
Defendants to strike it out in several affidavits and several Court hearings.
Today 18th December, 2012 as
adjourned from a brief hearing before High Court Judge Datuk David Wong in OPEN
court on 17th December, my writ was withdrawn by my learned Counsel
for a refile after some preliminary arguments that my merited action can be sustained
with the consent from the State AG on the Section 9 of Government Proceeding
Act 1956.
The Judge
Datuk David Wong stated the State AG did not give a retrospective consent for
the existing suit to proceed.
Counsel for
the Defendants argued that the Writ as a consequence of the short ruling by the
earlier hearing before Tuan Lee to set aside the Court Order, the Writ should
face similar fate on technical grounds and preliminary objections..
After some
bargaining on costs on both sides, the Judge decided to award RM5,000 costs to
the Defendants.
My counsel
Mr Rakhbir argued that the costs should be zero, as it is a public interest and
the Defendant case had involved public fund and that merits of the my Writ have
yet to be tried and the plaintiff has nothing to gain except to demand justice
from a person holding the position of Bishop.
The
Defendants’ lawyer was Mr Ronny Cham.
Prepared by
Joshua Y. C. Kong, Plaintiff- 18 Dec 2012